Discourse on Constitutional Court Decision No. 006/PUU-IV/2006 on Aceh KKR: Asymmetric Decentralization and Doelmatigheid Perspective

Abstract

Constitutional Court Decision No. 006/PUU-IV/2006 resulted in the dissolution of the KKR institution. However, did this decision also impact the Aceh KKR, or did it remain under the asymmetric decentralization regime? This issue ultimately led to uncertainty, leading this article to attempt to find a compromise. Using normative legal research methods, this article has shown that, first, the legal dualism regarding the Aceh KKR's position occurred because the Constitutional Court did not provide a confirmation of the Aceh KKR's status in the ruling. Second, the Aceh KKR was formed with a very special pattern, both historically and in its framework, thus gradually differentiating itself from the national KKR. Third, in terms of asymmetric decentralization and the doelmatigheid aspect, placing the Aceh KKR under this regime is far more reasonable than following the national KKR's axis. Therefore, this article is of the view that placing the Aceh KKR within the framework of asymmetric decentralization is the ideal response to the friction of this dualism in the Aceh KKR.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Published
2026-07-31
Section
Articles