Isuse Of Pkpu (Suspension Of Debt Payment Obligations) As An Instrument Of Pressure Against Debtors: An Analysis Of Legal Certainty And Protection Within Indonesia's Bankruptcy System
Abstract
The Suspension of Debt Payment Obligations was introduced within Indonesia's bankruptcy regime as a legal mechanism to facilitate debt restructuring, preserve business continuity, and provide financially distressed debtors with an opportunity to negotiate settlement agreements with their creditors. In practice, however, PKPU has increasingly been used as a coercive litigation strategy rather than a genuine restructuring instrument. Creditors frequently file PKPU petitions to pressure debtors into making immediate payments, even in circumstances where the debtors remain financially viable and are capable of fulfilling their obligations through ordinary commercial arrangements. This practice has raised significant concerns regarding legal certainty, procedural fairness, and the balance of interests between creditors and debtors. Previous studies have primarily focused on the procedural aspects of PKPU or its effectiveness in resolving commercial disputes, while relatively little attention has been devoted to the misuse of PKPU proceedings and their implications for debtor protection and the integrity of Indonesia's bankruptcy system. This study addresses that gap through normative juridical research employing statutory, conceptual, and case study approaches to analyze relevant commercial court decisions. The findings reveal that the existing legal framework governing PKPU petitions lacks clear standards for establishing insolvency and good faith, thereby creating opportunities for procedural abuse and inconsistent judicial practice. Accordingly, this study recommends strengthening the regulatory framework by introducing stricter preliminary evidentiary requirements, defining objective indicators of good faith and insolvency, and reinforcing the court's supervisory role during the initial examination of PKPU petitions to ensure greater legal certainty, procedural fairness, and balanced protection for both creditors and debtors.