The Application of the Business Judgment Rule in Determining the Criminal Liability of Directors of BUMN for Corruption Offences in Indonesia

Abstract

The Business Judgment Rule (BJR) serves as a fundamental corporate law doctrine designed to protect directors from personal liability arising from business decisions that involve inherent commercial risks. In the context of BUMN, however, the application of the BJR frequently intersects with anti-corruption law, creating legal uncertainty when business decisions resulting in state financial losses are subsequently subjected to criminal prosecution. This study aims to examine the application of the BJR in determining the criminal liability of directors of BUMN in corruption cases and to analyze the legal issues arising from the inconsistency between corporate law principles and criminal law enforcement. This research employs a normative legal research method using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. The study analyzes relevant provisions of the National Criminal Code, the Anti-Corruption Law, the Company Law, the BUMN Law, Constitutional Court decisions, Supreme Court Circular Letters, and judicial decisions concerning corruption cases involving directors of BUMN. The findings reveal that although the BJR has been recognized within Indonesian positive law, its implementation in corruption cases remains inconsistent. Law enforcement authorities and courts often prioritize the existence of state financial losses without adequately assessing whether the directors acted in good faith, based on sufficient information, free from conflicts of interest, and in the best interests of the company. This inconsistency generates a chilling effect on directors and undermines legal certainty. The novelty of this research lies in proposing the systematic integration of BJR standards into anti-corruption law enforcement through regulatory reform, judicial guidelines, and the harmonization of corporate law, BUMN law, and criminal law.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Published
2026-07-31
Section
Articles